This is similar to the system we used in JB on FFXI. It worked really well. We never used deductions though. Everything was worth 1 point and had to be an announced event so as to make it fair to everyone. Lotting rights started at the top and went down the point list. We never had problems with not getting items we wanted, and those who showed up were repaid in kind for their hard work.
That requires some planning, but keeps the playing field level. Its worth it. That way a random event doesn't break out just because enough people are on which isn't fair to those who are not.
Of course the loot system is much more simple in XIV, but keeping up with attendance points for scheduled events is a good idea in case the system is every changed or tweaked.

Silvano Conri Admin replied
725 weeks ago